Penalty and Liquidated Damages

Written by  //  February 28, 2011  //  Corporate Law and Business  //  25 Comments

The importance in commercial law of the easy enforceability of particular contractual devices cannot be overstated, and the payment of damages on breach of contract is a good illustration. If the law applied the usual mechanism of proving loss for every claim, a claimant will often be unable to recover damages effectively and expeditiously. To avoid the inconvenience that this causes, the English courts developed the doctrine of liquidated damages by which the parties could agree in advance that a breach of contract would trigger the payment of a fixed sum of money as damages. Since this was the intellectual foundation of the doctrine, it followed that a sum disproportionate to foreseeable loss (“penalty”) could not be given effect to in the same way. The rule meant that if the sum stipulated was found to be a “penalty”, the claimant had to prove loss in the usual way, although if actual loss exceeded the sum named as penalty, he could recover the higher sum. Conversely, if the sum stipulated was found to be a reasonable estimate and therefore liquidated damages, the claimant was confined to that sum, even if actual loss exceeded it. This branch of the law became considerably complex in England, since it was difficult to predict into which category a contractual provision for the payment of damages would fall. Interested readers may refer for a more elaborate discussion to the leading decision in Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre.

The Indian legislature obviated the need to resort to the difficult exercise of distinguishing between a penalty and liquidated damages by enacting the simple rule in s. 74 of the Contract Act that a court may award “reasonable compensation” not exceeding “the sum named” in the contract as payable in the event of breach, or any other stipulation by way of penalty. As the Constitution Bench put it in Fateh Chand, the Indian legislature dispensed with this “web of presumptions”. I have discussed elsewhere the significance of the 1899 amendment in light of the recent decision of the Supreme Court in BSNL v Reliance. It suffices here to note that, subject to one important qualification, it is unnecessary to distinguish between a penalty and liquidated damages in India. The qualification is that s. 74 allows a court to award such reasonable compensation “whether or not actual damage or loss is proved to have been caused”, and the Supreme Court has held that the sum named in the contract will be taken to represent reasonable compensation in any case where it is unable to assess actual loss (Maula Bax v Union of India AIR 1970 SC 1995). In short, in a significant number of cases, the claimant is entitled to the benefit of a liquidated damages clause without further ado. However, the Court has also held that this benefit is unavailable if the sum is thought to represent a penalty – not, as in English law, because that makes it unenforceable, but because there is then no reason to consider that the sum reflects “reasonable compensation”.

The significance of this distinction has been considered by the Delhi High Court in its recent judgment in Sudhir Gensets v Indian Oil Corporation. The appellant, Sudhir Gensets [“SGL”] had agreed to supply certain equipment to IOC by a specified deadline, and Clause 13 of the contract provided that it would pay liquidated damages of 0.5 % of the value of the goods delayed per week, subject to a maximum of 10 % of the total value. SGL, for a variety of reasons, could not supply in time, and a finding of fact was made that the fault was not that of IOC. Accordingly, IOC deducted (the significance of this is considered at the end) a sum of about Rs. 10 lakh, and SGL challenged it in arbitration proceedings on the ground that IOC had not adduced proof of loss.

Before the High Court, obvious reliance was placed by IOC on the language of s. 74, and the proposition advanced was that it is unnecessary to offer proof of loss. The High Court, after a detailed reference to the decision of the Supreme Court in ONGC v Saw Pipes, accepted this contention, holding that the figure in question represented the value the parties placed on the loss IOC would suffer on account of any delay in delivery. The Court rightly clarified that this result would not follow if the sum named in the contract is found to be a penalty, because there is then no room to assume that it represents a reasonable estimate of losses or “reasonable compensation” for the purpose of awarding damages under s. 74. The following observations are apposite:

28. This is also so provided under Section 74 of the Contract Act. As such, the party claiming breach of contract is entitled to receive reasonable compensation whether or not actual loss is proved to have been caused by such breach. In view of ONGC vs. Saw Pipes, wherever there is a pre-determined amount for the damages, in such a situation the said amount can be deducted by way of liquidated damages by way of specified amount payable by the respondent. Thus, if the compensation is named in the contract by way of penalty, consideration would be different and the party is only entitled to reasonable compensation for the loss suffered. But if the compensation named in the contract for such breach is genuine pre-estimate of loss which the parties knew when they made the contract to be likely to result from the breach of it, there is no question of proving such loss or such party is not required to lead evidence to prove actual loss suffered by him [emphasis added].

A final point must be made. It is interesting to notice in this case that Clause 13 provided that the vendor would pay the said sum as liquidated damages, and not that the purchaser could withhold or deduct that sum. Is there a difference between a claim to damages on the completion of the cause of action, and the crystallised right to enforce the claim once it is part of a decree? In Union of India v Raman Iron Foundry, the Supreme Court held (in a different context) that there is, albeit in a different context, and therefore declined to construe a contractual provision as allowing the deduction of mere claims. That case was overruled in Kamaluddin Ansari v Union of India and it is accepted that a contract can in any event provide for a claim to be appropriated prior to crystallisation – although whether the IOC-SDL contract did so is not clear.

About the Author

V. Niranjan is an Advocate in India. He graduated from the National Law School of India University, Bangalore, and is presently a BCL candidate at Magdalen College, University of Oxford. He also contributes to Indian Corporate Law - indiacorplaw.blogspot.com.

View all posts by

25 Comments on "Penalty and Liquidated Damages"

  1. Dhananjaya May 30, 2011 at 7:37 am ·

    Nice piece Niranjan. Is there any literature/case law on how to ascertain whether an amount stipulated to be paid in a contract is by way of penalty or by way of liquidated damages?

  2. dr.pkaditya April 21, 2012 at 5:07 am ·

    Really great views. Kindly comment on the following narration in a contract:

    “Security deposit of Rs. xx lacs shall be for the due and faithful performance of the contract and shall stand forfeited as compensation for any loss resulting from failure of the contractor to fulfill obligations in executing the work”.

    Is there any scope for demanding amount more than the above xx lacs ?

  3. Indo Ispat August 4, 2012 at 2:04 pm ·

    Sir,
    we need judgement no & date of Hon`ble Supreme Court on liquidity damage (L.D.) on delay delivery of material.
    Since , we suffering same problem from Govt.Orgns, Since 2000, which are deducting (L.D) from our bill without proof of loss certificate from their user. Subsequently made our payment beyond order terms.and abnormal delay continue violate payment terms ,
    Due to this ,we suffering both side losses to pay interest to our bank for their made delay payment and deducted L.D.by Govt. Orgns and never pay interest to us for their made delay payment.
    We are SSI unit kindly cooperate us to avoid to become a sick unit.
    Kindly Regards,
    Indo Ispat,
    Jagat Jain.
    Prop
    033-24554142

  4. P.K. Rathi September 18, 2013 at 7:26 am ·

    In turn key contract there is a clause according to which progress to be monitored every six months ans if progress is less by 20% vis-a-vis milestones then penalty @ 0.1% on shortfall shall be levied till shortfall is made up. Employer did not monitor progress as per schedule but levied penalty after a period of one year. Can he do so ? If not reference of rulings is required.

  5. P.K. Rathi October 4, 2013 at 5:07 am ·

    In works contracts both parties to contract fail to perform their part of obligations, but employer exercise his power and levy penalty on the contractor and starts recovery of penal amount. Can he do so? Do we have decisions of Courts to prove that the action of the Employer is illegal.

  6. top skin care products for sensitive skin April 29, 2014 at 5:45 am ·

    I knnow this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my
    own blog and wass curious what alll is needed
    tto get set up? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny?
    I’mnot very internet smart so I’m not 100% sure.
    Any tips oor advice would be greatly appreciated.Kudos

    Also visit my weboage :: top skin care products for sensitive skin

  7. piano moving and Storage Seattle May 19, 2014 at 4:11 am ·

    Insurance secures you against worst case scenarios and
    hence you shouldn’t take it lightly. Buying your own home is
    one of the biggest investments and commitments that most people will
    experience in a lifetime. Average cost of home survey report is $530 (£350).

    Have a look at my weblog; piano moving and Storage Seattle

  8. what are keratin treatments for hair May 19, 2014 at 2:06 pm ·

    Keep the mixture cooled and pat it on your lips as often as necessary.
    Prepare a paste of gram (Cicer arietinum) flour in raw milk.
    Inlcude fish, whole grains, legumes, dairy products, and fresh fruits and vegetables to prevent wrinkles and maintain healthy skin.

    my site what are keratin treatments for hair

  9. Day Summer Camp Delray Beach May 21, 2014 at 8:41 pm ·

    I had to demonstrate abilities and earn respect in my new role.
    You may want to go ahead and finish off the Legion soldiers in the
    other barracks. Now you can learn the secrets behind your favorite movie action sequences.
    All too often, kids these days waste away their afternoons playing video games.
    Summer can be focused on sports, music, games, horseback riding, archery, golf, swimming, boating, nature life,
    crafts, dance, or any variety of activities.
    Surf House Accommodation: 1 Week 550 euros All-Inclusive.
    However, it is often found that after a few weeks boredom begins
    to set in for lots of kids. For girls wanting
    to camp in a medieval castle, Vermont offers this plus a life sized Viking sail boat.
    Try to include contrasting elements in the picture, or contrasting colours.

    The bunk was where he slept, sat and generally lived while in the cabin.

    Review my web site – Day Summer Camp Delray Beach

  10. celebrity dress up ideas June 27, 2014 at 12:37 am ·

    In simple words, fashion illustration gives a freedom to the artist to
    put forward the fashion designs and ideas in front of the entire world.
    Laughter, smiles and playfulness were the norm for his photos,
    but it was not in fashion photography. It’s nice that at least parts of society and
    media are recognizing that not all women are shaped the same
    and we don’t all need to be a size 6 or smaller.

    my site … celebrity dress up ideas

  11. hcg Drops reviews July 1, 2014 at 11:11 am ·

    But keep in mind the key to lose weight through walking is walking in slow manner and in a rhythm.
    It was something I had to research and explore, since
    my patients were asking for it, and I had really
    turned away from this approach. Some people claim that HCG
    itself does not produce any significant weight loss.

    Feel free to visit my web page hcg Drops reviews

  12. Best Fake Tan July 6, 2014 at 4:59 am ·

    But, when you go for your spray tan and you don’t prepare your skin, your tan won’t last as long.

    You want to hydrate and provide comfort to your clients but still provide them with that great
    tan that they are looking for. Whether the course content is relegated to an in-person, online
    or DVD experience, expect to learn the proper use of airbrush equipment, safely aspects of sunless tanning and skin prep and application techniques unique to this industry.
    Despite this, sunbathing is becoming very unpopular because of its
    extreme side-effects. If you notice many models and stars are nicely
    tanned, this is also because airbrush tanning covers many of their flaws and also makes them appear thinner
    and more attractive. There are several renowned cosmetic companies in the market, making
    new tanning products introductions each day. This kind of sunless tanning prevents sunburns, which is a common problem with sunbathing.

    By way of the 1970s and 80s, individuals were becoming busier.
    Recently the spray tanning products are delivered using can which enclosed with latest tanning technology
    and because of the people. If you keep your home neat and
    clean dust mites can be controlled.

    Have a look at my site – Best Fake Tan

  13. moving services west palm beach July 10, 2014 at 6:18 pm ·

    Rather than doing it themselves, many people
    would agree they need expert hands for the jobs. Some companies will make an adjustable crankset for shorter
    or taller people too. They usually provide long distance mover provides services to
    the customer who wants it from them.

    Feel free to surf to my web site moving services west palm beach

  14. Womens health and fitness July 18, 2014 at 3:56 pm ·

    In an internet forum about plastic surgery, it will be possible to come in contact with other individuals about plastic surgery
    through the net. In recent years the term “mommy-makeover” has become more common. The couple broke up in 1937 as Lamarr finally escaped to London by drugging him.

    Feel free to visit my web-site :: Womens health and fitness

  15. capillus272 heidi montag before and after September 10, 2014 at 11:00 pm ·

    This herbal solution will help you achieve picture perfect hair
    once more. Eventually this can cause hair thinning or patches of bald spots.
    Such devices as KTP, ERBIUM, Pulse DYE and Alexandrite have short length of laser light waves, and they are very effective for removing unwanted hair on a light colored
    skin.

    Feel free to visit my web site; capillus272 heidi montag before and after

  16. plastic surgery charlotte nc September 14, 2014 at 1:07 pm ·

    How you look at plastic surgery depends first and
    foremost on how you appear at your require. The “Basketball Wives LA” star also
    made waves recently when she appeared with Drake and Blake Griffin in a skit for the ESPY Awards.
    Plastic surgery procedures for the most part, are considered, major surgery.

    Visit my site: plastic surgery charlotte nc

  17. facial plastic surgeon wall nj September 15, 2014 at 2:12 am ·

    In Wales there was a proverb reflecting the power of this plant:
    “No mistletoe, no buck”. There are quite a few
    qualified cosmetic surgeons overseas who are notable for producing quality,
    amazing, and flawless results. In case that you have
    a medical problem or imperfections in the nasal area, this treatment are often a great help.

    Take a look at my website – facial plastic surgeon wall nj

  18. riquisimo chocolate bar recipe September 28, 2014 at 4:05 pm ·

    In a blind panic, І opeened a spare bottle off
    sparkling ԝine I had about thee house even though I’d hoped not to have to drimk tɦat day.

    “The list of people below are all members of the 27 club, having been musicians that died at the age of twenty seven. It is a fusion of popular dance musics from the West such as jazz, soul, Latin, and rock blended with sabar, the traditional drumming and dance music of Senegal.

    Also visit my web blog: riquisimo chօcolate
    bar recipe

  19. Great article.

  20. Hester June 2, 2015 at 2:22 pm ·

    It is not my first time to visit this web site, i am visiting this web page dailly and obtain fastidious information from here all the time.

  21. Supernoches June 29, 2015 at 6:08 pm ·

    has quickly caesud images of their house to spread everywhere.a0 More details can be found on the Digital Earth Blog or the Smoking Gun. Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers

  22. Good day I am so glad I found your blog page, I really found you by error,
    while I was researching on Aol for something else, Nonetheless
    I am here now and would just like to say thank you for a fantastic post and a all round exciting blog (I also love the
    theme/design), I don’t have time to look over it all at the moment
    but I have saved it and also included your RSS feeds,
    so when I have time I will be back to read more, Please do
    keep up the fantastic jo.

  23. http://tinyurl.com July 20, 2015 at 6:23 pm ·

    I would like to thank you for the efforts you have put in penning
    this blog. I’m hoping to check out the same high-grade blog
    posts from you later on as well. In fact, your creative writing abilities has motivated me to get my own site now ;)

  24. nhacaiquocte.com July 21, 2015 at 4:00 am ·

    Have a look at the world’s largest casino through following photos.
    In an effort to attract players, numerous online casinos offer players free
    casino money to play with. Live dealer roulette and live dealer blackjack tournaments are probably played the most, and the convenience of playing from
    your home computer makes this experience second to none.

  25. Hello colleagues, how is everything, and what you desire to say regarding this
    post, in my view its really remarkable designed for me.

Comments are now closed for this article.