<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
		>
<channel>
	<title>Comments on: Karma and rationality</title>
	<atom:link href="/philosophyreligionculture/karma-and-rationality/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>http://www.criticaltwenties.in/philosophyreligionculture/karma-and-rationality</link>
	<description>Powered by Webshore</description>
	<lastBuildDate>Wed, 02 Sep 2015 13:53:54 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<sy:updatePeriod>hourly</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>1</sy:updateFrequency>
	<generator>http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1</generator>
	<item>
		<title>By: Dr. Ajit R. Jadhav</title>
		<link>http://www.criticaltwenties.in/philosophyreligionculture/karma-and-rationality#comment-902</link>
		<dc:creator>Dr. Ajit R. Jadhav</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 27 Oct 2010 10:16:25 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.criticaltwenties.in/?p=1291#comment-902</guid>
		<description>Karma is an ill-defined term. It virtually means anything to anyone, and no one takes the care to define it carefully---basing it within a framework of some valid preceding concepts. 

Now, if you factor-in the central place that the term occupies in the ancient Indian philosophy, the term actively becomes an &quot;anti-concept.&quot; [ http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/anti-concepts.html ]

With that said, I still maintain that the above still does not mean that Karma always necessarily has to be an invalid concept. All that the above means is that this term is in need of examination, even of being defined carefully and objectively, before it is used.

The sense of the term Karma even as an approximately understood notion would be almost fully meaningless without also involving the closely related idea of reincarnation. 

Just the fact that reincarnation has not been a part of the more rational philosophies in the West (notably, Aristotle, and now, Ayn Rand) does not mean that it is an arbitrary idea. However, again, this concept, too, has to be first demonstrated to be capable of rational understanding.

An important observation that can be made right away, however, is this: namely, that even if there is such a thing as a law of Karma, it still cannot violate the more basic philosophic ideas such as the primacy of existence over consciousness. 

In other words, assuming the present-day mainstream understanding of the term Karma, even if you accumulate good Karma in this life-time, it still remains an attribute of your soul. Even after assuming that the soul might transmigrate across life-spans, you cannot expect the soul to exceed natural laws---even a tranmigrating soul would be bound by the laws of nature; it cannot be a supernatural entity.

A highly naive, simple-minded---and  let me hasten to add, not (yet) carefully or objectively validated---way to look at it would be this. If you practise some skill over one lifetime, you would get not only a particular body of knowledge but also a certain kind of efficacy. The efficacy, or some residue of it, to allow speculation, might get transmitted across life-times. Yet, a really important point is what you can at all do with any form of efficacy right in this lifetime: just because you are efficacious (as a great surgeon might be), it does not mean that you thereby become omnipotent---not even in that particular respect (your surgery can still fail). As such, even if the efficacy, knowledge (or some residual form of it) does get transmitted across life-times, you cannot expect that residual form to miraculously overcome the natural bounds in the next life-time.

Another important point (and I promise this is the last one, for this reply at least :) ). Any notion of Karma would necessarily have to logically succeed---not precede---the idea of volition (i.e. free will). Thus, not only do you actually have to exercise volition in order to gain efficacy in this life time (all of the preceding in this statement is objectively demonstrable), even if there is some residue of it that remains in some form before your next life time (and here we already are in the realm of speculation), and even if that residue &quot;comes along&quot; with you in your next life-time, it still would be useless even in the next lifetime unless you exercise your volition and make use of it, in the next lifetime. A singer might have great &quot;born&quot; talents, speculatively because of the great practice in his last birth. But what if, he chooses to waste it away?

Some of the most basic fundamentals of a rational philosophy (by which I mainly mean Ayn Rand&#039;s) do not stand to change even if the ideas of reincarnation and Karma are some day shown to be valid.

Thanks for a good, thought-provoking topic. And, thanks for your patience in reading through! :)

Best,

--Ajit
[E&amp;OE]</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Karma is an ill-defined term. It virtually means anything to anyone, and no one takes the care to define it carefully&#8212;basing it within a framework of some valid preceding concepts. </p>
<p>Now, if you factor-in the central place that the term occupies in the ancient Indian philosophy, the term actively becomes an &#8220;anti-concept.&#8221; [ <a href="http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/anti-concepts.html" rel="nofollow">http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/anti-concepts.html</a> ]</p>
<p>With that said, I still maintain that the above still does not mean that Karma always necessarily has to be an invalid concept. All that the above means is that this term is in need of examination, even of being defined carefully and objectively, before it is used.</p>
<p>The sense of the term Karma even as an approximately understood notion would be almost fully meaningless without also involving the closely related idea of reincarnation. </p>
<p>Just the fact that reincarnation has not been a part of the more rational philosophies in the West (notably, Aristotle, and now, Ayn Rand) does not mean that it is an arbitrary idea. However, again, this concept, too, has to be first demonstrated to be capable of rational understanding.</p>
<p>An important observation that can be made right away, however, is this: namely, that even if there is such a thing as a law of Karma, it still cannot violate the more basic philosophic ideas such as the primacy of existence over consciousness. </p>
<p>In other words, assuming the present-day mainstream understanding of the term Karma, even if you accumulate good Karma in this life-time, it still remains an attribute of your soul. Even after assuming that the soul might transmigrate across life-spans, you cannot expect the soul to exceed natural laws&#8212;even a tranmigrating soul would be bound by the laws of nature; it cannot be a supernatural entity.</p>
<p>A highly naive, simple-minded&#8212;and  let me hasten to add, not (yet) carefully or objectively validated&#8212;way to look at it would be this. If you practise some skill over one lifetime, you would get not only a particular body of knowledge but also a certain kind of efficacy. The efficacy, or some residue of it, to allow speculation, might get transmitted across life-times. Yet, a really important point is what you can at all do with any form of efficacy right in this lifetime: just because you are efficacious (as a great surgeon might be), it does not mean that you thereby become omnipotent&#8212;not even in that particular respect (your surgery can still fail). As such, even if the efficacy, knowledge (or some residual form of it) does get transmitted across life-times, you cannot expect that residual form to miraculously overcome the natural bounds in the next life-time.</p>
<p>Another important point (and I promise this is the last one, for this reply at least <img src='/wp-includes/images/smilies/icon_smile.gif' alt=':)' class='wp-smiley' />  ). Any notion of Karma would necessarily have to logically succeed&#8212;not precede&#8212;the idea of volition (i.e. free will). Thus, not only do you actually have to exercise volition in order to gain efficacy in this life time (all of the preceding in this statement is objectively demonstrable), even if there is some residue of it that remains in some form before your next life time (and here we already are in the realm of speculation), and even if that residue &#8220;comes along&#8221; with you in your next life-time, it still would be useless even in the next lifetime unless you exercise your volition and make use of it, in the next lifetime. A singer might have great &#8220;born&#8221; talents, speculatively because of the great practice in his last birth. But what if, he chooses to waste it away?</p>
<p>Some of the most basic fundamentals of a rational philosophy (by which I mainly mean Ayn Rand&#8217;s) do not stand to change even if the ideas of reincarnation and Karma are some day shown to be valid.</p>
<p>Thanks for a good, thought-provoking topic. And, thanks for your patience in reading through! <img src='/wp-includes/images/smilies/icon_smile.gif' alt=':)' class='wp-smiley' /> </p>
<p>Best,</p>
<p>&#8211;Ajit<br />
[E&amp;OE]</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
	<item>
		<title>By: Shivprasad</title>
		<link>http://www.criticaltwenties.in/philosophyreligionculture/karma-and-rationality#comment-866</link>
		<dc:creator>Shivprasad</dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 26 Oct 2010 11:16:29 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.criticaltwenties.in/?p=1291#comment-866</guid>
		<description>Akshat, 

Rather than take a long and circuitous route involving evaluating from an Archimedan point over your own attitudes, you could have always taken a straighforwardly rational route to dismissing the popular concept of psuedo-karma. ( Just to distance the pop conception from the real deal , I am calling it psuedo-karma). 

To anyone who gives it some thought, psuedo karma will be found to be illogical, counterintuitive, contradictory and paradoxical. If there is any aspect of our thought and action that is &#039;determined&#039; by chance luck or destiny, we will have to logically admit that the whole of our life is governed by luck chance or destiny. There will then be no way of seiving out the determined ones from free willed ones. Imagine if you say that I was &#039;destined&#039; to do action X, the question arises what are the properties of the action that constitute destiny. You will find that just the same properties are present in case of every action.  It willbe possible to argue that each stimulus, each though and each action was just as predestined as action X.

The great philosopher Bernard Williams had argued that once you admit that luck determines any aspect of your action, then it will swallow human agency altogether.  And the same thing holds good the other way around as well. If you hold that any of our actions are out of free will, then there can be no scope whatsoever for destiny. 

Just see how psuedo karma is paradoxical. It admits that some aspects of your life are your own choice and that some others are the result of some sort of destiny. This is paradoxical. Usually when some concept is illogical, it is a good indicator that it may be a wrong one.</description>
		<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Akshat, </p>
<p>Rather than take a long and circuitous route involving evaluating from an Archimedan point over your own attitudes, you could have always taken a straighforwardly rational route to dismissing the popular concept of psuedo-karma. ( Just to distance the pop conception from the real deal , I am calling it psuedo-karma). </p>
<p>To anyone who gives it some thought, psuedo karma will be found to be illogical, counterintuitive, contradictory and paradoxical. If there is any aspect of our thought and action that is &#8216;determined&#8217; by chance luck or destiny, we will have to logically admit that the whole of our life is governed by luck chance or destiny. There will then be no way of seiving out the determined ones from free willed ones. Imagine if you say that I was &#8216;destined&#8217; to do action X, the question arises what are the properties of the action that constitute destiny. You will find that just the same properties are present in case of every action.  It willbe possible to argue that each stimulus, each though and each action was just as predestined as action X.</p>
<p>The great philosopher Bernard Williams had argued that once you admit that luck determines any aspect of your action, then it will swallow human agency altogether.  And the same thing holds good the other way around as well. If you hold that any of our actions are out of free will, then there can be no scope whatsoever for destiny. </p>
<p>Just see how psuedo karma is paradoxical. It admits that some aspects of your life are your own choice and that some others are the result of some sort of destiny. This is paradoxical. Usually when some concept is illogical, it is a good indicator that it may be a wrong one.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
	</item>
</channel>
</rss>
